Oral tobacco not safe substitute
11/11/2005 New York, NY Megan Rauscher Yahoo News (news.yahoo.com) Smokeless oral tobacco products such as moist snuff and hard snuff lozenges are not a safe alternative to cigarettes for people trying to kick the habit, as these products contain high levels of cancer-causing compounds. Instead, the best aids appear to be medicinal nicotine replacement products such as the nicotine patch or gum as these products contain only trace amounts of cancer-causing compounds, according to research presented at a cancer prevention conference in Baltimore this month. Dr. Stephen Hecht and colleagues from the University of Minnesota Cancer Center in Minneapolis compared the levels of cancer-causing nitrosamines in popular smokeless tobacco products and medicinal nicotine products such as the nicotine patch, nicotine gum, and nicotine lozenges. The results "clearly showed that the levels of cancer-causing nitrosamines are far higher in smokeless tobacco products than they are in medicinal nicotine products," Hecht said during a press briefing. Nitrosamine levels were highest in oral snuff tobacco products made in the US, following by Swedish 'snus' (another type of smokeless tobacco), whereas the lowest levels were found in hard snuff lozenges. The snuff lozenges actually did "quite well in our study -- it does appear to have lower levels of carcinogenic nitrosamines" than most of the other smokeless tobacco products, Hecht said. By contrast, only trace amounts of these cancer-causing nitrosamines were found in the nicotine patch and gum. While smokeless tobacco has "demonstrably less carcinogens and toxins than cigarette smoke," said Hecht, smokeless tobacco [...]